Saturday, March 5, 2011

Clearance based on false claims

http://www.downtoearth.org.in/node/1733

Clearance based on false claims

Facts & Realities of Bhavanapadu Thermal Power Project (TPP) -Capt J.Ramarao

Facts & Realities of Bhavanapadu Thermal Power Project (TPP)

1) The TPP is being located in ecologically sensitive Naupada Swamps/ Wetlands of considerable importance

A) Extract from the Minutes of 34 th meeting of EAC held on 10-11 Nov 2008

In accordance with the decision taken during the EAC meeting held on June 11-12, 2008, the site visit was made by a sub group of EAC during July 21-23, 2008 and the sub group presented its observations which are as under:-

The project site is a swamp area, and is an integral component of unique eco system of marine, terrestrial, brackish and fresh water ecological site with their own specific floral and faunal characteristics. The component of these unique eco systems are the Naupada swamps (Marine), Telineelapuram area (Terrestrial) and Tekkali creek (Brackish and Marine). This swamp / mud flat together serve as biologically rich wetland. It is ecologically rich and diverse and a home for some of the highly endangered species of Evi fauna. Further, the region also includes an identified important bird site (IBS at Telineelapuram). The area command high ecological importance as wetland habitat, priority area for conservation as important bird area, feeding areas for winter migrants, breeding area for spot billed pelicans and representative area of remnant salt water marsh lands. A position of the project is therefore likely to directly conflict with conservation objectives.


B) In the 17 th Meeting of the Standing Committee of National Board for Wild Life held on 22-12-2009, under the chairmanship of the Minister for E&F, the site inspection report of Dr.Asad Rahmani and Dr, Asha Rajvanshi had clearly stated that Naupada Swamps area was an excellent habitat for Migratory Birds and was classified as Important Bird Area (IBA). It also stated that the entire area of the project, starting from the approach road to the project site is marshy land and the EIA Report ignored Bio diversity of the area.

C)The NEAA in its Order dated 30-8-10 observed that even after leaving 500 acres of land in southern portion, thereby shifting the southern boundary of the facility by1.35 km, the remaining area (part of which already raised), was still found to be a marshy/wetland. The Authority further observed that as stated by the expert of BHNS & agreed by Dr.Kaul, an internationally renowned expert on Wetlands, elevation of the project site by the project proponent, after the grant of E C, has caused irreversible changes in the character of the Wetland. The Authority also observed that these wetlands have been converted for agricultural use & at least 10% in the locality has since been converted so far, including the raised project site and being Ecologically Important, there should be a Total Ban on further conversion

2) The EAC ignored all the representations, including the observations of its Sub-Committee regarding the ground realities about Naupada Swamps and recommended the project for granting E.C and MoEF had chosen to issue the EC for the project by its Letter dated 2-4-2009 and remained silent spectator there after. The NEAA observed that various reports in this regard, including that of sub-committee of EAC were found to be incorrect. The EAC & in turn the MOEF has relied on these reports for granting E.C for the Power Project of ECEPL at Bhavanapadu.

3) Suppression of facts and Misleading Information The EIA Report in respect of ECEPL TPP appears to have deliberately suppressed/ concealed the information regarding the location of the project in Wetland Area & failed to mention the presence of Telineelapuram–Important Bird Area Site (IBAS) within 2.5 Km from the project site.
With regard to ecological sensitivity of the area, the certification by the Principal Chief Conservator of Forests of AP that there are no National Parks, Sanctuary, Elephant/Tiger Reserve, Migratory Path (existing as well as proposed) within 10 Km radius of the project site is nothing but deliberate misleading information and suppression of the fact of the presence of Telineelapuram –IBAS- within 2.5 Km from the proposed project site.
The MOEF justified the granting of Environmental Clearance for the ECEPL Project, in spite of the reservations expressed by the Sub-committee of EAC, saying that Dept. of E&F, Govt of AP, vide its letter of 09-02-09, confirmed that the project site does not fall within Naupada Swamps and there are no conservation sites near the project site. This suppresses the fact of the presence of Telineelapuram –Important Bird Area Site (IBAS) within 2.5 Km from the project site. and the ground reality that the project site is marshy/wetland. It also ignores the fact that Naupada Swamps is one of the 55 wetlands prioritized for conservation by the AP Forest Dept

4) Cancellation of E.C by Regulatory Authority

As the Environmental Clearance (EC) granted by MoEF to Bhavanapadu Thermal Power Project, is based on misleading information, and suppression of the ground realities, the EC is liable for cancellation in accordance with Paragraph 8 (vi) of EIA Notification of 2006 which stipulates deliberate concealment and/or submission of false or misleading information or data which is material to screening or scoping or appraisal or decision on the application shall make the application liable for rejection, and cancellation of prior environmental clearance granted on that basis.

Permitting the project to continue in the present location amounts to violation of Hon’ble Supreme Court Judgment dated 28, January, 2011 in Civil Appeal No1132 /2011 with regard to Common Lands.
Conclusion:
No useful purpose will be served by taking up review of compliance of conditions of Environmental Clearance (EC) by the Expert Appraisal Committee, which is a party for recommending E C based on incorrect / misleading reports/ information, ignoring the facts and ground realities brought to its notice. It will only result in further delay and amount to window dressing to cover up the lapses.
The E.C granted to Bhavanapadu TPP of ECEPL at the present location, based on incorrect reports as observed by NEAA,, be cancelled by MOEF which is the competent Regulatory Authority, after giving a personal hearing to the Project Proponent, and following the principles of natural justice, with out delaying further by going through the process of EAC Meeting which has become irrelevant now.
The G.O.Ms.No 1108 of 15-09-2008 allotting Govt Wetlands to the project be cancelled by the Government of Andhra Pradesh, in compliance with Hon’ble Supreme Court Judgment dated 28, January, 2011 in Civil Appeal No.1132/2011 with regard to Common Lands.
Necessary penal action be considered & initiated in accordance with Sections 15, 17 and 19 of The Environment (Protection) Act, 1986, against the Officials responsible for suppressing the ground realities & submitting incorrect/misleading reports in respect of the project.
_________________________________________________

Friday, March 4, 2011

WET LANDS ARE NOT WASTE LANDS!!

http://countercurrents.org/nazareth030311.htm

Wetlands Are Not Wastelands!

By Marianne de Nazareth

03 March, 2011
Countercurrents.org

It’s a constant battle to save wetlands everywhere in the world by environmentalists, with the galloping pressure of human populations exploding by the minute. With industrialization too land use patterns are changing and wet and marshy lands which are considered wasteland by the common man are being dredged and built over. It is in the hands of environmentalists and the media to educate policy and decision makers about the importance of these wetlands and the need to preserve them.

To define a weland : Wetlands are the transitional area between aquatic and oceanic areas and dry terrestrial ecosystems. The Ramsar Convention has defined wetlands as "areas of marsh, fen , peatland or water, whether natural or artifical, permanent or temporary with water that is static or flowing, fresh, brackish or salt, including areas of marine water the depth of which at low t ide does not exceed six meters". Wetlands include, marshes, swamps, open water bodies, mangroves, tidal flats and salt marshes which exist in every country.

Questions abound as to why it is necessary to save a wetland. In India, they are were regarded as ‘wasteland’ to the common man.Wetlands however are integral to a healthy environment,as they help to retain water during dry periods, thus keeping the underground water table high and relatively stable. During periods of flooding, they help to reduce flood levels and to trap suspended solids and nutrients before they flow directly into lakes.

Therefore they act like a live filter and the removal of such wetland systems because of urbanization or otherwise causes the quality of water in the lakes to degenerate. In addition, wetlands are important feeding, breeding and drinking areas for wildlife and are home to large numbers of migratory water birds. As with any natural habitat, wetlands are important in supporting the diversity of species and have a complex and important part to play in the food chain. In a recent millenium assessment of ecosystems, freshwater biodiversity has been placed on the top as the most threatened of all types of biodiversity due to vanishing wetlands.

Saraswati speaking to villagers about wetland

The value of wetlands is now being brought home to the common man through activists and environmental journalists like us in India. That is why Saraswati Kavula an environmental activist rushed out to Kakrapalli village in Andhra Pradesh, India, to lend support to the villagers when they were protesting loss of wetlands in their village.
The villagers have been protesting peacefully against the construction of 2400 MW of Coal Fired Thermal Power plant of M/s East Coast Energy Pvt. Ltd since August 2010. “Instead of listening to the peoples requests, the police have been set on them and they are going from door to door beating up the villagers,” said Saraswati Kavula Joint Convener National Alliance of People’s Movements (AP Chapter) her voice shrill with emotion.

“The entire project has been given permission by suppressing the facts about the Naupada Wetlands in Srikakulam District calling them ‘wastelands’ and not an important biodiveristy hotspot that they really are.”

The disputed site of M/s East Coast Energy Pvt. Ltd which is setting up a 2460MW Coal fired thermal power plant is located within the internationally recognised Wetland system of Naupada swamps and just 2.5 kms away from an Important Bird Area Site (IBAS) Telineelapuram.The birds of Telineelapuram have been declared endangered species and recorded in the Red Book of IUCN (International Union for Conservation of Nature). Therefore, according to environmental laws of India and the RAMSAR Convention to which India has been a signatory, Wetlands are protected areas, where no polluting activity can be taken up.

“Every year, Siberian birds come to live here. More importantly, about 18 village panchayats with a population of a few thousand households will be losing their livelihood with this construction. Though it is illegal according to Indian law to construct anything on a wetland, they have got the permission and all enviro clearances. When the issue came up in court, the court said, "well since they have already constructed in the 1000 acres, let them leave the rest of the area as it is and continue to complete the project," revealed Saraswati.

In the last monsoon, when the outlets to the sea got blocked due to the construction, the excess water could not go out, and flooded the region and submerged nearly 3000 acres of crop land. The inland fishermen who lived by fishing in the wetland - now don't get any fish as the fish grow only in a mix of the fresh and sea water. Many began to starve, so the local farmers began to stop the car of the Senior General Manger and his colleague when they visited the project area. The local people also started a relay hunger strike which is already into its 150th day.

Saraswati and her colleagues have now written to the Chairperson, Andhra Pradesh Human Rights Commission, Hyderabad and hopes justice will be done.

(The writer is adjunct faculty, St. Joseph’s College and COMMITS, Bangalore and a media fellow with UNFCCC, UNEP and Robert Bosch Stiftung)



Thursday, March 3, 2011

Review of Bhavanapadu TPP of ECEPL by EAC should not be an Eye-Wash !-Capt J.Ramarao

Review of Bhavanapadu TPP of ECEPL by EAC should not be an Eye-Wash !-Capt J.Ramarao

Further to letter dated 01-03-2011 regarding Bhavanapadu TPP, this is to bring to your kind attention, the preemptive efforts of ECEPL to dilute the review, by giving front page advertisements in the News Papers stating that they have complied with all Laws & Regulations, all Permits and Clearance obtained, submitting a factual report to EAC on steps taken in full compliance of stipulations and to demonstrate that there have been no violations of any condition whatsoever etc .

Why Review by EAC at this Stage ?

Time and again the suppression of facts & ground realities by the project proponent and the concerned State Govt agencies, just to hasten the formality of getting EC, had been brought to the notice of EAC, MOEF and the State Govt, both before EC was granted and there after. But unfortunately the EAC ignored all the representations, including the observations of its Sub-Committee regarding the ground realities about Naupada Swamps and recommended the project for E.C and MoEF had chosen to issue the EC for the project by its Letter dated 2-4-2009 and remained silent spectator there after.

In the 17 th Meeting of the Standing Committee of National Board for Wild Life held on 22-12-2009, under the chairmanship of the Minister for E&F, the site inspection report of Dr.Asad Rahmani and Dr, Asha Rajvanshi had clearly stated that Naupada Swamps area was an excellent habitat for Migratory Birds and was classified as IBAS. It also stated that the entire area of the project, starting from the approach road to the project site is marshy land and the EIA Report ignored Bio diversity of the area.

The National Environment Appellate Authority (NEAA) in its order dated 30-08-2010 observed that even after leaving 500 acres of land in southern portion, the remaining area, was still found to be a marshy. The Authority also observed that various reports in this regard, including that of sub-committee of EAC were found to be incorrect. The EAC and in turn the MOEF has relied on these reports for granting E.C for the project.

Justice Delayed - Justice Denied

After a lapse of nearly two years and Police Firing on 28th February 2011, leading to killing of two and injuring many innocent, peaceful & unarmed protestors, and a question was raised in Parliament on the subject, the MOEF reacted to the situation, as if it is a fresh case. If only the MOEF had been sensitive, responsive, proactive and not yielded to political pressures, the unfortunate incident could have been avoided. As long as we do not have an independent and autonomous Environment Protection Authority (EPA) for strict enforcement of Environmental Law, we will continue to be terrorized and be the victims of GDP oriented Development and Corporate Terrorists.

Review by EAC is Irrelevant

As the EC granted by MoEF to Bhavanapadu TPP,is based on misleading information, and suppression of the ground realities , the EC is liable for cancellation in accordance with Paragraph 8 (vi) of EIA Notification of 2006.What useful purpose will be served by taking up review of compliance of conditions of E C by the EAC which is a party for recommending E C based on incorrect / misleading reports/ information? It will only result in further delay.

Swift and Decisive Action Required

The E.C granted to Bhavanapadu TPP at the present location, based on incorrect reports as observed by NEAA,, be cancelled by MOEF which is the competent Regulatory Authority, after giving a personal hearing to the Project Proponent, and following the principles of natural justice, with out delaying further by going through the process of EAC Meeting which has become irrelevant now.

The G.O.Ms.No 1108 of 15-09-2008 allotting Govt Wetlands to the project be cancelled by the Government of Andhra Pradesh, in compliance with Hon’ble Supreme Court Judgment dated 28, January, 2011 in Civil Appeal No.1132/2011 with regard to Common Lands.

Necessary penal action be considered & initiated in accordance with Sections 15, 17 and 19 of The Environment (Protection) Act, 1986, against the Officials responsible for suppressing the ground realities & submitting incorrect reports in respect of the project.

Innocent children left in the lurch


http://www.hinduonnet.com/thehindu/thscrip/print.pl?file=2011030452630700.htm&date=2011/03/04/&prd=th&
K. Srinivasa Rao

Innocent children left in the lurch

With their parents detained by police, they wander without proper food, shelter

SRIKAKULAM: Several children of Vadditandra, Akasalakhavaram and Kakarapalli are forced to eke out a living as their parents have been detained.

Police took many villagers, including elderly persons and women a week ago, on the charge that they were violating Section 144 imposed in the respective villages. A few of them were produced to court and later sent to jail.

Missing people

But, the whereabouts of the remaining people, numbering over 100, is not known to their family members and relatives. They were searching in vain in police stations located in Tekkali, Santabommali, Narsannapeta and other places.

Worst affected are the children of Vadditandra village, aged between three and nine, as their parents were detained even before the fire accident in which about 50 houses were gutted on February 28. After the devastation, the remaining villagers could not take care of the children. Dayanidhi, a 5th class student told The Hindu that his mother Bhudevi was taken away by police and his father was afraid of entering the village. His sisters Anita and Sita were also wandering in the village without proper food and shelter. “I was frightened by the smoke bombs, which were hurled in our school premises. My teacher Murthy was also hurt,” he said.

N. Dhanumani, a fisherman alleged that his mother Rukmunamma (66) was forcibly taken into custody.

A woman called Chinnammi was also worried about her husband Mangu Lakshmana Rao who was missing for the last few days. “I request police officials to tell us at least about his whereabouts,” she added.

The police department withdrew forces from the villagers as situation was under control in many villages on Wednesday. The officials said all the detained villagers were safe and would be produced in the court after filing the charge sheet.

‘Suspend works'

Meanwhile, the District Collector N. Srikanth said the government asked the East Coast Energy Private Limited to suspend works till further orders. According to him, the government will take a decision on March 7 when experts would meet and review the permissions given to the plant.

© Copyright 2000 - 2009 The Hindu

Wednesday, March 2, 2011

FBV plea to Jairam Ramesh

http://www.hindu.com/2011/03/03/stories/2011030362660500.htm

FBV plea to Jairam Ramesh

Special Correspondent

VISAKHAPATNAM: Forum for Better Visakha convener E.A.S. Sarma asked Union Minister of State for Environment and Forests Jairam Ramesh to be firm on cancelling clearances accorded to the thermal power plant being set up at Kakarapalli.

Hailing Mr. Ramesh's statement in Parliament, Mr. Sarma, a former IAS officer, expressed his satisfaction over the admission by the Minister that the project was located within a wetland system.

MoEF order

“It was factually a correct statement. This is what the National Environment Appellate Authority (NEAA) had categorically stated in its order of July 9, 2010. This is an issue on which NEAA had come to a clear finding. Unless it is challenged, it cannot be reopened by anyone, neither by the Ministry of Environment and Forests (MoEF) nor by the Expert Appraisal Committee (EAC).”

MoEF in its Monday's order asked the East Coast Energy Pvt. Ltd to stop construction work immediately and sought a status report from the State government. It stated that the EAC at its meeting scheduled on March 7 will discuss the compliance of conditions laid down in the environmental clearance given to the company.

Mr. Sarma, a former Union Power Secretary, said the National Environment Policy approved by the Union Cabinet had mandated the conservation of wetlands in accordance with the Constitutional directive under Article 48A.

“As the Minister in charge of MoEF, you are bound by the spirit of that Article and the avowed policy of the government. You have no freedom to find “tradeoffs” between environment and an ongoing project,” he stated in the letter.

Thermal power projects under microscope

http://www.hindu.com/2011/03/03/stories/2011030356600500.htm


Thermal power projects mired in controversies

Santosh Patnaik

MoEF under pressure to review clearances to units in North coastal Andhra


We are opposed to setting up of thermal power plants against public mandate: eco activist

Preference of investors to coal instead of gas, which is aplenty in KG basin, raises doubts


VISAKHAPATNAM: With growing criticism over North coastal Andhra turning into a pollution cauldron, the Ministry of Environment and Forests (MoEF) is under pressure to review clearances given to several coal-fired power projects in the region.

The Central Pollution Control Board has already identified Visakhapatnam as a highly polluted industrial cluster. With several pollution- causing units proposed in and around Visakhapatnam, environmentalists as well as pro-development lobbyists are engaged in a fight of sorts in support of their respective viewpoints.

Killing of innocent protesters in police firing in two incidents – at Sompeta and Kakarapalli, when they registered their protest against private power plants proposed at Sompeta and near Bhavanapadu, has revived the hope among green activists that the Centre would stop adopting a soft approach towards the project proponents.

Swamp lands

All thermal power projects, which have been strongly opposed by senior Congress MP V. Kishore Chandra Deo as well as former Union Power Secretary E.A.S. Sarma and others, are mired in controversies right from land acquisition to the manner in which public hearings were held and swamp land was shown as wasteland.

“We are not against development. But we are opposed to violation of rules by setting up thermal power plants in swamp lands and against public mandate,” Krishna Murthy, president of Paryavarana Parirakshana Sangham, told The Hindu. The sangham is spearheading the agitation against the power plant at Sompeta.

After the Sompeta firing six months ago, the National Environment Appellate Authority cancelled the environmental clearance given to 1320 MW power plant of NCC Power Projects Limited.

A day after another police firing killing two innocent fishermen at Kakarapalli, the MoEF on Tuesday gave a directive to suspend construction work of 2640 MW plant by East Coast Energy Pvt. Ltd (ECEPL). The Expert Appraisal Committee will review the criticism over thermal power projects at its meeting scheduled on March 7. The MoEF has asked the committee to study the compliance of conditions attached to the environmental clearance for the ECEPL's power project proposed with super critical technology.

Controversies are haunting the thermal power project because of the allegation that transportation of coal will lead to lot of pollution. The preference of investors for coal instead of gas, which is available in plenty in Krishna - Godavari basin, also raises several doubts. Already, there is a lot of criticism over damage caused due to ash-pond by power plants located in coastal areas, displacement of fishermen and violation of Coastal Regulation Zone (CRZ) guidelines.